Re: Strat comparisons
Posted: Mon Jun 22, 2020 6:03 pm
My brother-in-law's partner plays bass for him these days. Just sayin'.sizzlingbadger wrote:never ceases to amaze me what you can find on YouTube.
My brother-in-law's partner plays bass for him these days. Just sayin'.sizzlingbadger wrote:never ceases to amaze me what you can find on YouTube.
I'm increasingly of the opinion that we're allowing the tone quest to stifle creativity and just the simple business of becoming better players.jeremyb wrote:So John Mayer has some interesting wiring going on in the silver sky and the pickups are voiced with scooped mids, like his earlier pickups, the big dippers, fascinating! Must be something to do with the combination of amps he uses that makes it all sounds so good...
As vicarious claims to fame go, thats not really a good one...Molly wrote:My brother-in-law's partner plays bass for him these days. Just sayin'.sizzlingbadger wrote:never ceases to amaze me what you can find on YouTube.
Mmmmm going down the pickup hole at the moment and when I listen to fancy ones beside my tex-mexs there's not much in it... I'm sure it's mostly psychological!!Molly wrote:I'm increasingly of the opinion that we're allowing the tone quest to stifle creativity and just the simple business of becoming better players.jeremyb wrote:So John Mayer has some interesting wiring going on in the silver sky and the pickups are voiced with scooped mids, like his earlier pickups, the big dippers, fascinating! Must be something to do with the combination of amps he uses that makes it all sounds so good...
The longer I sit next to my amp the more critical of my tone I become. But the first five minutes sounds fantastic.
It is a bit lame, eh?Bg wrote:As vicarious claims to fame go, thats not really a good one...Molly wrote:My brother-in-law's partner plays bass for him these days. Just sayin'.sizzlingbadger wrote:never ceases to amaze me what you can find on YouTube.
Not even a blood relation... so you're lucky thereMolly wrote:It is a bit lame, eh?Bg wrote:As vicarious claims to fame go, thats not really a good one...Molly wrote:
My brother-in-law's partner plays bass for him these days. Just sayin'.
I have 3 Strats each with different pups and while there is quite a sound difference, in the end they all sound the same ‘cos it’s just me playing them...jeremyb wrote:="Molly"]
Mmmmm going down the pickup hole at the moment and when I listen to fancy ones beside my tex-mexs there's not much in it... I'm sure it's mostly psychological!!
After years of tweaking, I have come to the conclusion that this is the truth.Rog wrote:I have 3 Strats each with different pups and while there is quite a sound difference, in the end they all sound the same ‘cos it’s just me playing them...jeremyb wrote:="Molly"]
Mmmmm going down the pickup hole at the moment and when I listen to fancy ones beside my tex-mexs there's not much in it... I'm sure it's mostly psychological!!
Fixed.Rog wrote:I have 3 Strats each with different pups and while there is quite a sound difference, in the end they all sound the same ‘cos they’re just strats...jeremyb wrote:
Mmmmm going down the pickup hole at the moment and when I listen to fancy ones beside my tex-mexs there's not much in it... I'm sure it's mostly psychological!!
I think pickups are one of the only components on an electric guitar that have measurable and audible differences. How they work in your particular guitar with your particular style and rig is of course another thing.jeremyb wrote:Mmmmm going down the pickup hole at the moment and when I listen to fancy ones beside my tex-mexs there's not much in it... I'm sure it's mostly psychological!!Molly wrote:I'm increasingly of the opinion that we're allowing the tone quest to stifle creativity and just the simple business of becoming better players.jeremyb wrote:So John Mayer has some interesting wiring going on in the silver sky and the pickups are voiced with scooped mids, like his earlier pickups, the big dippers, fascinating! Must be something to do with the combination of amps he uses that makes it all sounds so good...
The longer I sit next to my amp the more critical of my tone I become. But the first five minutes sounds fantastic.
lol. The truth is that there are Strats and everything else. Of course the ‘everything else’ are just pretenders to the throne.Starfire wrote:Fixed.Rog wrote:I have 3 Strats each with different pups and while there is quite a sound difference, in the end they all sound the same ‘cos they’re just strats...jeremyb wrote:
Mmmmm going down the pickup hole at the moment and when I listen to fancy ones beside my tex-mexs there's not much in it... I'm sure it's mostly psychological!!
I would disagree with that now, after owning a guitar made from hard ash that does affect the electric tone, way more treble but also sustain, anything that alters how the string vibrates will change its tone,but before that I would have 100% agreed it was all just pickups with an electric!!MikeC wrote:I think pickups are one of the only components on an electric guitar that have measurable and audible differences. How they work in your particular guitar with your particular style and rig is of course another thing.jeremyb wrote:Mmmmm going down the pickup hole at the moment and when I listen to fancy ones beside my tex-mexs there's not much in it... I'm sure it's mostly psychological!!Molly wrote:
I'm increasingly of the opinion that we're allowing the tone quest to stifle creativity and just the simple business of becoming better players.
The longer I sit next to my amp the more critical of my tone I become. But the first five minutes sounds fantastic.
Watched this series as Rabea went from one spendy set to another and, I think, ended up back where he started.jeremyb wrote:
I would disagree with that now, after owning a guitar made from hard ash that does affect the electric tone, way more treble but also sustain, anything that alters how the string vibrates will change its tone,but before that I would have 100% agreed it was all just pickups with an electric!!
The more I listen to various strat pickups, the more I reckon that pickups have less of an effect than people believe, and given theres no consistent way of testing them blind, as well as human error in the playing coming into the equation too what can we believe?!??!?!
Yeah been following Rabea's "journey" too, I really like the sound of the Ron Ellis 50/60 set that Mick put in his blue strat until I found a price online...Molly wrote:Watched this series as Rabea went from one spendy set to another and, I think, ended up back where he started.jeremyb wrote:
I would disagree with that now, after owning a guitar made from hard ash that does affect the electric tone, way more treble but also sustain, anything that alters how the string vibrates will change its tone,but before that I would have 100% agreed it was all just pickups with an electric!!
The more I listen to various strat pickups, the more I reckon that pickups have less of an effect than people believe, and given theres no consistent way of testing them blind, as well as human error in the playing coming into the equation too what can we believe?!??!?!
My Strats are chalk and cheese. One has a big maple, quarter-sawn neck and one-piece ash body with 50s' pickups, and the other is Alder, skinnier rosewood neck, CS69 pickups. The latter is pure Knopfler though the 69 set might be a bit too bright. Contemplating a change. The maple/ash/50s is not what I think I'm looking for in a Strat. Might not be the keeper I pronounced it to be (surprise, surpise...). Very cool to look at, beautifully put together but not exactly what I want from a Strat.
Christ, it never ends...